| Mark | Aaron | Kemet | Nate | Brandon | Anne | Sara | Dave | Eriks | Amy | JC | Carol | |
| 1 | Tony Romo | Adrian Peterson | LaDainian Tomlinson | Randy Moss | Steven Jackson | Aaron Rodgers | Peyton Manning | Frank Gore | Steve Slaton | Philip Rivers | Jones Drew | Drew Brees |
| 2 | Matt Forte | Michael Turner | Tom Brady | DeAngelo Williams | Chris Johnson | Larry Fitzgerald | Brian Westbrook | Brandon Jacobs | Clinton Portis | Reggie Wayne | Marion Barber | Reggie Bush |
| 3 | Anquan Boldin | Steve Smith | Ryan Grant | Kurt Warner | Roddy White | Greg Jennings | Joseph Addai | Carson Palmer | Donovan McNabb | Derick Ward | Ronnie Brown | Andre Johnson |
| 4 | Marques Colston | Jay Cutler | Calvin Johnson | Knowshon Moreno | Pierre Thomas | Darren McFadden | Terrell Owens | Chad Ochocinco | Wes Welker | Santonio Holmes | TJ Housh... | LenDale White |
| 5 | Jonathan Stuart | Willie Parker | Jason Witten | Larry Johnson | Anthony Gonzales | Steelers Defense | Kevin Smith | Roy Williams | Dwayne Bowe | Darren Sproles | Bernard Berrian | Cedric Benson |
| 6 | Matt Schaub | Vincent Jackson | Thomas Jones | Marshawn Lynch | Matt Hasselbeck | Willis McGahee | Matt Cassel | Matt Ryan | Ben Roethlisberger | Ely Manning | Lawerence Maroney |
Antonio Bryant |
| 7 | Dallas Clark | Tim Hightower | Lee Evans | Percy Harvin | Chris Beanie Wells | Stephen Gostkowski | Antonio Gates | DeSean Jackson | Donald Brown | Devin Hester | Brett Favre | Braylon Edwards |
| 8 | Rob Bironas | Brandon Marshall | David Akers | Joe Flacco | Trent Edwards | Tony Gonzales | Torry Holt | Mason Crosby | Ray Rice | Ryan Longwell | Chester Taylor | LeSean McCoy |
| 9 | Titans Defense | Giants Defense | Chargers Defense | Baltimore Defense | Laveranues Coles | Felix Jones | Vikings Defense | Shonn Green | Eddie Royal | Jamal Lewis | Julias Jones | Kris Brown |
| 10 | Cowboys Defense | Kyle Orton | Michael Jenkins | Lance Moore | Eagles Defense | Robbie Gould | Nate Kaeding | Packers Defense | Jerricho Cotchery | Chicago Defense | Ted Ginn | Jets Defense |
| 11 | Rian Lindell | RIcky Williams | David Garrard | Neil Rackers | Santana Moss | Daunte Culpepper | Shane Graham | Rashard Mendenhall | Nick Folk | Adam Vinatieri | Jason Elam | Hines Ward |
| 12 | Leon Washington | Matt Prater | Earnest Graham | Visanthe Shiancoe | Owen Daniels | Josh Scobee | Derrick Mason | Donald Driver | Cardinals Defense | Michael Crabtree | Patriots Defense | Shawn Hill |
| 13 | Nate Burleson | Steve Smith (Giants) | Donny Avery | Washington Defense | Fred Jackson | Seattle Defense | Sidney Rice | Houston Defense | Josh Brown | Fred Taylor | Nate Washington | Dolphins Defense |
| 14 | Greg Olson | Le'Ron McClain | Joe Nedney | John Carney | Lawerence Tynes | Isaac Bruce | Tampa Defense | Jason Hanson | Buffalo Defense | Indianapolis Defense | Michael Vick | Steven Hauschka |